The story
Elliot (Michael Showalter), a tax accountant from Brooklyn, is a dependable though thoroughly average young man doomed to be the "Baxter", the nice guy who's bound to lose the girl to the leading man in romantic comedy. Losing three girlfriends to last-minute rekindled relationships with their ex-boyfriends has made Elliot wary of being abandoned yet again.
Story from TheTVDB.
Where to Watch
Where-to-watch data by JustWatch · every service.
Cast
Michael Showalter
Elliot Sherman

Elizabeth Banks
Caroline Swann

Michelle Williams
Cecil Mills

Justin Theroux
Bradley Lake
Zak Orth
Wendall Wimms

Michael Ian Black
Ed
Catherine Lloyd Burns
Stella

Peter Dinklage
Benson Hedges

Paul Rudd
Dan Abbott
Katharine Powell
Sonya Simmons
Jon DeVries
Alan Swann
Donna Mitchell
Judy Swann
Haviland Morris
Kate Lewis
David Wain
Louis Lewis
Jim DeMarse
Leonard Sherman
Leslie Lyles
Sheila Sherman
A.D. Miles
Bar Baxter #1

Joe Lo Truglio
Bar Baxter #2
Seth Herzog
Bar Baxter #3
Jonathan Marc Sherman
Deaf Bar Baxter
Peter Stadlen
Young Elliot

Abby Wathen
Kimberly
Gabriel Millman
Max

Sarah Drew
Serena
More Like This

Yoh! Bestie
2026 · ★ 6.2

Zoey 102
2023 · ★ 6.9

Easy Virtue
2008 · ★ 6.5

The Right Kind of Wrong
2013 · ★ 5.9

Keeping the Faith
2000 · ★ 6.1

The Wrong Paris
2025 · ★ 6.7

Little Italy
2018 · ★ 6.6

She's Funny That Way
2015 · ★ 5.9

Your Christmas or Mine?
2022 · ★ 6.4

Valentine's Day
2010 · ★ 5.9

To All the Boys: P.S. I Still Love You
2020 · ★ 6.8

The Other End of the Line
2007 · ★ 6.5

Relationship Goals
2026 · ★ 6.3

It Happened One Night
1934 · ★ 7.8

Think Like a Man Too
2014 · ★ 6.4

Chasing Papi
2003 · ★ 6.7

Good Advice
2001 · ★ 5.9

Cousins
1989 · ★ 6.0

Boot Camp
2024 · ★ 6.1

Crossing Delancey
1988 · ★ 5.9
What People Are Saying
Enjoyable enough, would have been much better if it wasn't so damn predictable Pretty much something trying to be different than the usual rom/coms only to really just be another one.
Read it on themoviedb.org