The story
Jamie (Catherine Keener) informs her ex-husband John (John C. Reilly) that she is getting married. Even though they have been apart for seven years, the news devastates John, who was already depressed. At a party the next night, John gets more and more drunk until he ends up urinating in the bushes, where Molly (Marisa Tomei) strikes up a conversation. Molly goes back to John's house but leaves during the night, after they have had sex. Molly returns for dinner the next night, and again leaves after they have had sex. John follows her to her house and falls asleep in his car. The next morning, he approaches the house and meets Molly's 21-year-old son Cyrus (Jonah Hill). Cyrus invites John inside and makes friendly conversation with him. Molly is startled to see John in her house when she returns, but the trio have dinner together. John is unnerved by the unnatural intimacy between Molly and Cyrus.
Story from TheTVDB.
Where to Watch
Where-to-watch data by JustWatch · every service.
Cast

John C. Reilly
John Kilpatrick

Jonah Hill
Cyrus Fawcett

Marisa Tomei
Molly Fawcett

Catherine Keener
Jamie

Matt Walsh
Tim
Kathy Ann Wittes
Ashley
Diane Mizota
Thermostat Girl
Katie Aselton
Pretty Girl
Jamie Donnelly
Pastor

Tim Guinee
Roger

Steve Zissis
Rusty
Bill 'Bunky' Miller
Cyrus
Charlie Brewer
Stranger at Reception
Mitch Carter
Additional Voice (voice)

Newell Alexander
Additional Voice (voice)
Steve Alterman
Additional Voice (voice)
More Like This

Numb
2007 · ★ 5.9

Enemies, a Love Story
1989 · ★ 6.3

Why Did I Get Married Again?
2026 · ★ 6.6

The Best You Can
2025 · ★ 7.0

Irreplaceable You
2018 · ★ 7.0

Mumford
1999 · ★ 6.5

The Giant Mechanical Man
2012 · ★ 6.5

Jack Goes Boating
2010 · ★ 6.0

Delirious
2007 · ★ 6.3

How to Please a Woman
2022 · ★ 6.3

Rosaline
2022 · ★ 7.1

Strictly Sexual
2008 · ★ 6.1

Nothing Like the Holidays
2008 · ★ 6.3

Love Don't Co$t a Thing
2003 · ★ 7.7

Love Accidentally
2022 · ★ 6.1

The Elder Son
2006 · ★ 5.9

Walking and Talking
1996 · ★ 6.1

Breaking & Exiting
2018 · ★ 6.0

Cosi
1996 · ★ 6.2

XX/XY
2002 · ★ 6.0
What People Are Saying
I enjoyed this film, It made me giggle, quiet at times, not a lot of energy, but it didn't need it, and It came off very 'Cyrus' Super cast. It's one of them that makes you think something is going to happen or go the way that you think, but it doesn't, It's never straight forward, and It comes off creepy at times.
Read it on trakt.tvI thought it was a great flic. John C. Reilly is always believable and Marisa Tomei forever hot.
Read it on trakt.tvI've only recently discovered the magic that is the Duplass brother creations but I think this is the best one and it isn't close. While this film seemed to tread on so many different common themes it managed to avoid going down well-traveled roads. The main characters (especially Tomei) were fantastic and well-cast. I can imagine how this movie would have been absolutely butchered if it were a Hollywood production (it would have gone down the familiar roads). follow me at https://IHATEBadMovies.com or facebook page IHateBadMovies
Read it on trakt.tvDecent premise but really slow pacing (especially in the first 1/3 of the film) and ultimately I felt that the execution of the idea was underwhelming. Weird way to turn it super drama-heavy for the last 10 minutes. Kinda funny to have Reilly living in unit #13 tho.
Read it on themoviedb.org