The story
Karen (Blair) and Paul (Lee) are about to get married in Seattle. During his bachelor party, Paul has a chat with one of the dancers at the party, Becky (Stiles), and they find that they have an affinity for each other. Paul wakes up the next morning and is terrified to see Becky in the bed next to him. Assuming they slept together, Paul rushes Becky out of his apartment and hopes never to see her again. He tries to cover up the connection for the few days before the wedding. Unfortunately, Becky unexpectedly shows up around town and turns out to be Karen's cousin. Even worse, Becky's malicious ex-boyfriend Police officer Ray had Becky followed and photographed. Becky and Paul meet again to steal those pictures from Ray's apartment. Further problems arise with family and friends consistently showing up at the wrong times. Crabs, dirty underwear in the toilet tank, a horny best friend, and a best man/brother who is in love with the bride all provide for a week of wedding preparation hijinks. Through the snowballing of all his implausible lies and half-truths, Paul receives corroboration and support from an unexpected corner: what seems to be a coordinated network of other men, including friends, complete strangers and, to Paul's astonishment, Karen's own father; all who give the same explanation: "It's a guy thing".
Story from TheTVDB.
Where to Watch
Where-to-watch data by JustWatch · every service.
Cast

Jason Lee
Paul Morse

Selma Blair
Karen Cooper

Julia Stiles
Becky Jackson

Shawn Hatosy
Jim

Lochlyn Munro
Ray Donovan

James Brolin
Ken Cooper

Diana Scarwid
Sandra Cooper

David Koechner
Buck

Julie Hagerty
Dorothy

Thomas Lennon
Pete

Larry Miller
Minister Ferris (uncredited)

Jackie Burroughs
Aunt Budge

Jay Brazeau
Howard

Matthew Walker
Minister Green
Fred Ewanuick
Jeff
Lisa Calder
Tonya

Dan Joffre
Larry

Michael Teigen
Lou
Will Sanderson
Bachelor Party Guy
Dave McGowan
Bachelor Party Guy
Jonathon Young
Bachelor Party Guy
Daniel McKellar
Bachelor Party Guy
Scott Williams
The Buddy Scott Trio
Josef Pelletier
The Buddy Scott Trio
More Like This

I Want You Back
2022 · ★ 6.3

Playing It Cool
2014 · ★ 5.9

The Awful Truth
1937 · ★ 7.2

Everybody Loves Somebody
2017 · ★ 6.5

Romance & Cigarettes
2006 · ★ 6.0

That Awkward Moment
2014 · ★ 6.1

I Love You to Death
1990 · ★ 6.4

Revenge of the Bridesmaids
2010 · ★ 6.6

Broadcast News
1987 · ★ 6.8

The Wedding Ringer
2015 · ★ 6.5

Starting Over
1979 · ★ 6.4

About Last Night
2014 · ★ 6.0

Bachelor Party
1984 · ★ 6.3

Someone Like You...
2001 · ★ 6.0

Adam's Rib
1949 · ★ 7.1

¿Quieres ser mi hijo?
2023 · ★ 8.4

American Wedding
2003 · ★ 6.2

Love Crazy
1941 · ★ 6.8

Two Can Play That Game
2001 · ★ 6.5

The Wrong Missy
2020 · ★ 6.1
What People Are Saying
We chose this movie because we loved Jason Lee's work on _My Name is Earl_. He does not disappoint here, seemingly playing nearly the same character. Overall the movie is cookie-cutter, you have seen this story dozens of times. There are a few nuances that may make or break it for you. The rehearsal dinner was quite the variable to see James Brolin and Julie Hagerty "stoned" certainly was unexpected and actually fairly funny.
Read it on trakt.tv_A Guy Thing_ is a mediocre, by-the-numbers romantic comedy. When Paul wakes up next to a strange woman after a wild batcher party, he tries to hide it from his fiancée, but things get complicated when he discovers that the woman is his fiancée’s cousin. Starring Jason Lee, Julia Stiles, and Selma Blair, the film has a solid cast. However, the plot is formulaic as all get-out; making it painfully predictable. And the comedy is incredibly broad, with a lot of low brow humor. Still, some of the jokes work, and Lee and Stiles are charming and do a good job with the comedy. It’s entertaining and delivers some laughs, but _A Guy Thing_ is completely forgettable.
Read it on trakt.tv>"l was talking about fear the other day with someone and it made me realize that l can't remember the last time I've been afraid." According to this movie, a guy thing: cheating and lying. LOL. Not one I will probably ever watch again but I appreciate Julia Stiles being charming in this.
Read it on trakt.tvDecent watch, might watch again, but hard to recommend. Don't get me wrong, I like the movie: it's well casted, has a decent story and production value, but even at the time of release, it wasn't great. There are some really funny moments, and if I were Jason Lee, I think I would have some trouble choosing between Selma Blair and Julia Stiles too, but it's mostly "what awful things can we do to him" humor. Ants under a magnifying glass just aren't all that satisfying. The upside is that there are some very cleverly crafted characters and acting even beyond that. There are plenty of probably better movies out there, especially after all this time.
Read it on themoviedb.org