
The story
This true-crime series investigates the 1998 disappearance of a 23-year-old woman from a Caribbean cruise and her family's tireless search for answers.
Story from TheTVDB.
Where to Watch
Where-to-watch data by JustWatch · every service.
Cast
Iva Bradley
Self - Amy’s Mother
Ron Bradley
Self - Amy’s Father
Brad Bradley
Self - Amy’s Brother
Erin Sheridan
Self - Special Agent FBI
Erin Cullather
Self - Amy’s Childhood Friend
Sarah Luck
Self - Amy’s Friend
David Carmichael
Self - Eyewitness
Kirk Detweiler
Self - Cruise Director
Adtzere Mentar
Self - Harbor Police Chief, Curaçao
Amica Douglas
Self - Alister Douglas’ Daughter
Julia Tracy
Self - Amy’s Friend
Jamie Barnett
Self - Cruise Safety Advocate
Kate Lovelace
Self - Amy’s Ex-Girlfriend
Victor McCollum
Self - Special Agent FBI
Chris Fenwick
Self - Passenger
Judy Maurer
Self - Eyewitness
Michael Clark
Self - Special Agent in Charge, FBI
Brent Hunter
Self - Guest Relations Manager
Henry Vrutaal
Self - Curaçao Coast Guard
Mollie McClure
Self - Amy’s Former Girlfriend
Stephanie Judd
Self - Amy’s Friend
Anthony Willis
Self - Online Investigator
Bill Hefner
Self - Eyewitness
Wayne Brietag
Self - Passenger
Seasons
More Like This

Death of the Pastor's Wife
2026 · ★ 7.3 · TV

Dateline
1992 · ★ 6.6 · TV

Killer Sally
2022 · ★ 6.7 · TV

Homicide Hunter: Lt Joe Kenda
2011 · ★ 8.9 · TV

Cold Justice
2013 · ★ 7.5 · TV

Conversations with a Killer: The Jeffrey Dahmer Tapes
2022 · ★ 7.7 · TV

Crime Scene: The Texas Killing Fields
2022 · ★ 6.5 · TV
Cold Case Files
2017 · ★ 7.9 · TV

How I Caught My Killer
2023 · ★ 7.1 · TV

Trust Me: The False Prophet
2026 · ★ 7.5 · TV

The Jinx
2015 · ★ 8.0 · TV

Homicide
2024 · ★ 7.0 · TV

Crime Scene: The Vanishing at the Cecil Hotel
2021 · ★ 6.9 · TV

The Yogurt Shop Murders
2025 · ★ 6.8 · TV

Lorena
2019 · ★ 6.6 · TV

See No Evil
2015 · ★ 8.1 · TV

Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter
2024 · ★ 7.7 · TV
The Killing Season
2016 · ★ 6.6 · TV

The Idaho Murders: College Nightmare
2026 · ★ 6.8 · TV

Worst Neighbor Ever
2026 · ★ 7.1 · TV
What People Are Saying
Completely devastating. I finished the documentary and spent some time thinking, this is the kind of story where, as a woman, you put yourself in the other person's shoes. What would you do if this had happened to you? I have a lot, a lot of empathy for Amy. She tried several times to ask for help, I wonder if she gave up or if she still has hope. I hope she's the one who sees the website, and I hope she sees that her family is still waiting to find her. I hope she knows. It wasn't suicide. She was trafficked. That photo of her in bed is clearly her. There have been many sightings of her over the years. The cruise is definitely part of this crime, they certainly knew and were facilitators. That talk from the cruise director is a lot of bullshit. They cleaned up the scene, let people leave and didn't help the family at all. They knew. Yellow is another one that is completely to blame, and Amy certainly wasn't the first and probably not the last that he helped to traffic. A suitcase full of photos of girls????? Okay my friend you're definitely not innocent. The guy who appeared in the documentary to say that he saw her at the illegal bar, that she asked him for help, and that he simply kept silent because he didn't want his pension to be reduced. Look, I wish only the best for him. Only the best. It's incredibly sad to think that there are people in the world who simply end someone's life for money. Who can simply live knowing they're exploiting other people. I don't believe in hell, but I hope there's some form of punishment for these people. I hope the universe punishes these people in the worst way possible for thinking they have the right to decide how another human being's life will be. For me, a person ceases to be human the moment they lack empathy. I don't want to be negative and say that maybe she's dead. I think it's like Schrodinger's box. There's a 50% chance she's dead and a 50% chance she's alive. So I'm going to root for her to be alive. Because it's not fair that Amy came into this world and just had this life. I'll root for any being in the universe to help her find her family again. And if she has children, may the children be saved along with her.
Read it on trakt.tvWhile I undertand the family and friends of Amy need to have hope she's still alive, I just think she fell off the ship. Everything else is too far fetched and Occam's razor and all that. It's very tragic but i just don't see any alternative presented in this documentary as plausible.
Read it on trakt.tvI gotta stop believing these shows have a happy ending
Read it on trakt.tvThere is nothing more I hate than when the social media clowns turned armchair detectives start posting out their dumbass theories.
Read it on trakt.tvContains spoilers — show it
Tragic. But ultimately a crap tv show. No real content or progress to the investigation. No reveal. No resolution. So pointless.
It absolutely hurts to say this, but I think the message in the bottle was a clue. It was sent a couple of weeks before the cruise. Then she got drunk, fell asleep on the balcony. I think probably when noticing she never received a reply from the girl she loved, while watching the sunrise, she might’ve jumped. 😞 I feel so sorry for the family and friends ❤️
Read it on trakt.tv