The story
Gray Baldwin (Heather Graham), a family oriented and quiet bachelorette, lives a close-knit life with her brother, Sam (Tom Cavanagh). Their lifestyle is generally co-dependent, involving them living together, going to dance classes together, etc. Gray and Sam's relationship has never been thought of as strange, but once a dinner party guest mistakes the siblings as a couple, Gray and Sam decide to venture outside of one another. While discussing with each other what they can do about their single lifestyles, and how they can "hook each other up" with a significant other, their conversation continues to the park, where Gray spots a possible girlfriend for Sam, Charlie Kelsey (Bridget Moynahan). Gray introduces herself, then Charlie to Sam, and they instantly bond, agreeing to see each other again.
Story from TheTVDB.
Where to Watch
Where-to-watch data by JustWatch · every service.
Cast

Heather Graham
Gray Baldwin

Bridget Moynahan
Charlie Kelsey

Tom Cavanagh
Sam Baldwin

Alan Cumming
Gordy

Sissy Spacek
Dr. Sydney

Molly Shannon
Carrie

Rachel Shelley
Julia Barlett
Bill Mondy
Jordan Phillips

Warren Christie
Trevor Brown
Don Ackerman
Conrad Spring
Campbell Lane
Harry

Samantha Ferris
Elaine
Tim Perez
Roberto
Ben Immanuel
Derek

April Telek
Laura Valentine
Alejandro Abellan
Juan

Patti Allan
Evelyn
Gloria Gaynor
Self

Kathryn Kirkpatrick
Carla
Kaaren de Zilva
Eva
Emily Anne Graham
Young Gray
Jack Di Blasio
Young Sam

Dan Joffre
Las Vegas Minister
More Like This

Chasing Papi
2003 · ★ 6.7

Crossing Delancey
1988 · ★ 5.9

Yoh! Bestie
2026 · ★ 6.2

Little Italy
2018 · ★ 6.6

The Wrong Paris
2025 · ★ 6.7

Easy Virtue
2008 · ★ 6.5

The Right Kind of Wrong
2013 · ★ 5.9

Boot Camp
2024 · ★ 6.1

Only the Lonely
1991 · ★ 6.2

Whisky Galore
2016 · ★ 5.9

Relationship Goals
2026 · ★ 6.3

Love Jacked
2018 · ★ 6.1

Then Came You
2020 · ★ 6.0

Your Christmas or Mine?
2022 · ★ 6.4

The Kissing Booth 2
2020 · ★ 7.6

Thunderstruck
2012 · ★ 6.2

Speechless
1994 · ★ 6.0

The Baxter
2005 · ★ 6.0

Lions Love
1969 · ★ 5.9

A Naija Christmas
2021 · ★ 6.7
What People Are Saying
This movie was so close to being really good yet our director seems to veer off course at every important point. I did love our introduction to Gray and Sam the brother/sister duo whose lives are so intertwined that several people mistakenly think they are a couple. As an aside, I did not know Heather Graham could dance so well. Back to the story. When they learn of the couple thing, they both get mildly weirded out and decide to find a partner for their sibling. Gray has shockingly amazing success on their first try when they run into Charlie in the park and she sets her up with Sam. Those two hit it off so well that we get a quick wedding. This sets off some biological explosion in Gray that has her suddenly feeling like she's gay. Dr. Sydney, her therapist(Sissy Spacek) can't seem to help. Luckily, Gray has befriended a super nice taxi driver Gordy who gives better advice than Merlin the Magician. Without giving too much away, that's your story. Bridget Moynahan was great but Alan Cumming as Gordy probably gets the most laughs. But is this comedy? Tough to tell. That's where I have a problem with the directing. Everything turns out too cute as Gray struggles with her "coming out". I don't have a problem with it not being realistic as some point out, I would just like it to be consistent instead of all over the place.
Read it on trakt.tv